Recent Blogs

Bitcoin Halving 2025: Why Retail Traders Lost Money Fast

By /

Bitcoin Halving 2025: Why 90% of Retail Traders Lost Money (And How I Did Too)

Introduction: My $2,400 Halving Disaster

I bought Bitcoin three weeks before the April 2024 halving. Not a little—$2,400 worth at $67,800 per coin. Everyone on crypto Twitter said the same thing: “Halvings always pump. Stock-to-flow model guarantees it. You’ll 3× your money in six months.”
I believed them.
The halving happened on April 20th, 2024. Bitcoin peaked at $73,200 two weeks later. I was up $190. Felt smart. Didn’t sell.
Then it dropped. $68,000. Then $62,000. By August 2024, Bitcoin hit $49,300, and my $2,400 was worth $1,730. I panic-sold at $51,200, locking in a $1,140 loss.
You know what happened next? Bitcoin rallied to $103,800 by December 2024. If I’d just held through the pain, I’d have been up $2,850 instead of down $1,140.
That’s a $3,990 difference because I didn’t understand what actually happens after Bitcoin halvings. And I wasn’t alone—90% of retail traders who bought the halving hype got destroyed the exact same way.
This isn’t another “buy Bitcoin and HODL” article. This is the brutal truth about why the 2024-2025 halving cycle crushed retail traders, what the institutions knew that we didn’t, and why I’ll never trade a halving the same way again.
For foundational crypto knowledge before diving into halving cycles, check our complete cryptocurrency trading guide first.

What Actually Is a Bitcoin Halving? (The Part Everyone Skips)

Yeah, yeah—everyone knows “the supply gets cut in half.” But here’s what nobody explains properly.

The Mining Reward Reality

Miners earn Bitcoin by keeping the network secure. About every 10 minutes, someone successfully mines a block and receives fresh Bitcoin as their payout.
Historical Rewards:
  • 2009-2012: 50 BTC per block
  • 2012-2016: 25 BTC per block (first halving)
  • 2016-2020: 12.5 BTC per block (second halving)
  • 2020-2024: 6.25 BTC per block (third halving)
  • 2024-2028: 3.125 BTC per block (fourth halving – current)
That April 2024 halving dropped miner revenue from 6.25 BTC to 3.125 BTC per block. Cut their income in half overnight.

Why This Matters (The Part That Wrecked Me)

Lower supply entering the market should mean higher prices, right? Basic economics—supply down, demand constant, price goes up.
That’s the theory everyone parrots on YouTube.
Reality? Way more complicated.
Miners need to sell Bitcoin to pay for electricity bills, equipment costs, and employee salaries. When their income gets halved, but their expenses stay the same, they’re forced to sell Bitcoin at whatever price they can get.
Short-term? That creates selling pressure, not the buying pressure everyone expects.
I didn’t know this. Bought three weeks before halving, thinking I was early. Turns out I was buying right into the top while smart money was distributing to idiots like me.

The Halving Pattern That Destroyed Retail Traders

Let me show you what actually happens. Not the “stock-to-flow will save you” nonsense—the real pattern from all four halvings.

The Pre-Halving Pump (Where I Got Trapped)

2-4 Months Before Halving:
Bitcoin rallies hard. Retail traders hear about it. FOMO kicks in. Everyone piles in expecting immediate riches after the halving.
2024 Example:
  • January 2024: Bitcoin at $42,800
  • March 2024: Bitcoin rallied to $73,200 (all-time high!)
  • Halving date: April 20, 2024
I bought it for $67,800 in late March. Thought I was early because we hadn’t hit the halving yet. Wrong.
The rally happened before the event. By the time the halving actually occurred, smart money had already taken profits, leaving retail holding the bag.

The Post-Halving Crash (Where I Lost $1,140)

1-6 Months After Halving:
Bitcoin doesn’t moon. It crashes. Sometimes 20-30%. Retail panics and sells at a loss.
Historical Post-Halving Drawdowns:
  • 2012 halving: -27% drop in the following 3 months
  • 2016 halving: -34% drop over next 5 months
  • 2020 halving: -19% drop within 2 months
  • 2024 halving: -33% drop (August low at $49,300)
See the pattern? Every. Single. Time.
But here’s what crypto influencers don’t mention in their “halving will make you rich” videos—those crashes are temporary. They’re shakeouts. Institutions are accumulating from panicked retail.

The Real Rally (12-18 Months Later)

Here’s the kicker that broke my heart.
The actual bull run doesn’t start until 12-18 months after the halving. Not immediately. Not in three months. Over a year later.
Historical Post-Halving Peaks:
  • 2012 halving (November) → Peak November 2013 (12 months later): +9,800%
  • 2016 halving (July) → Peak December 2017 (17 months later): +2,950%
  • 2020 halving (May) → Peak November 2021 (18 months later): +650%
  • 2024 halving (April) → Expected peak: September-December 2025
I sold at $51,200 in August 2024—right at the bottom of the post-halving shakeout. Four months later, Bitcoin hit $103,800.
If I’d just understood the cycle, I’d have known August was accumulation time, not panic-sell time.
⚠️ Brutal Reality: The Bitcoin halving doesn’t make you rich in six months. It sets up a cycle that plays out over 12-18 months. Retail traders who expect immediate results get slaughtered every single cycle.

Why 90% of Retail Traders Lost Money (I Was One of Them)

Let me break down the exact psychological traps that destroyed accounts in 2024-2025. I fell for three of these.

Trap #1: Buying the Pre-Halving Top

The Setup:
Bitcoin rallies from $42,800 (January) to $73,200 (March). Crypto Twitter explodes. “This is just the beginning!” “After halving, we’re going to $150,000!”
The Trap:
Retail FOMO’s in at $65,000-$73,000, thinking they’re early because the halving hasn’t happened yet. They don’t realize smart money has been accumulating since $25,000-$35,000 in 2023 and is now distributing to retail.
My Mistake:
Bought at $67,800, thinking I was catching the wave. Actually caught the distribution phase. Classic top buyer.
The Result:
Halving happens. Bitcoin peaks at $73,200. Then drops 33% over four months to $49,300. Retail panics and sells at massive losses.

Trap #2: The “This Time Is Different” Delusion

The Setup:
Every halving cycle, retail traders convince themselves that historical patterns no longer apply. “Institutional adoption changed everything!” “ETFs make this cycle different!”
The Trap:
Yeah, the details change. But the pattern doesn’t. Human psychology and market cycles repeat because people don’t change.
My Mistake:
I genuinely believed the Bitcoin ETF approvals (January 2024) meant we’d skip the post-halving crash and go straight to $100,000+. When the crash came anyway, I was psychologically unprepared.
The Result:
Same crash as 2012, 2016, and 2020. Just with different narratives. Retailers who believed “this time is different” got wrecked, as usual.

Trap #3: Weak Hands During the Shakeout

The Setup:
You bought Bitcoin before halving. It’s now down 25-30% from your entry. Every crypto influencer who told you to buy is silent. Your portfolio bleeds daily.
The Trap:
You panic sell at the bottom, locking in losses. Then watch Bitcoin rally 100%+ over the next year without you.
My Mistake:
Sold for $51,200 (August 2024) after watching my $2,400 drop to $1,730. Couldn’t stomach more losses. Bitcoin then rallied to $103,800 by December.
The Result:
Locked in -$1,140 loss instead of holding for +$2,850 gain. That’s a $3,990 mistake because I had weak hands during the shakeout phase.

Trap #4: Ignoring the Miner Capitulation

Here’s the trap almost nobody talks about.
The Setup:
Halving cuts miner revenue in half. Miners with high electricity costs or debt can’t survive. They’re forced to sell their Bitcoin reserves to stay operational.
The Trap:
This creates 2-4 months of consistent selling pressure post-halving. Retail doesn’t understand why Bitcoin keeps dropping “when supply just got cut in half.”
What Actually Happened (2024):
  • April 20: Halving occurs
  • April-August: Weak miners liquidate Bitcoin holdings to cover costs
  • August: Capitulation bottom at $49,300
  • September onward: Selling pressure exhausted, rally begins
My Mistake:
Didn’t know about the miner capitulation. Thought Bitcoin dropping meant “halving narrative was fake.” Sold right as the miner selling pressure was ending.
For a broader context on crypto market psychology, see our crypto security guide, which covers FOMO and panic selling.

What Institutions Knew (That Retail Didn’t)

Let me show you the game institutions played while retail got massacred.

Phase 1: Accumulation (2023)

What Happened:
Bitcoin ranged between $25,000 and $31,000 throughout most of 2023. Retail called it “boring” and stopped paying attention.
Institutions? Accumulating heavily.
The Data:
  • BlackRock filed for a Bitcoin ETF: June 2023
  • Institutional buying started: July-December 2023
  • Bitcoin slowly climbed from $25,000 → $42,000
Retail wasn’t buying because there was no hype. No excitement. Just slow grinding upward.

Phase 2: Distribution (Q1 2024)

What Happened:
Bitcoin rallied from $42,000 (January) to $73,200 (March). Crypto Twitter exploded. Retail FOMO’d in.
Institutions? Selling to retail.
The Evidence:
Exchange inflows spiked massively in January-March 2024. That’s coins moving to exchanges—the first step before selling. Institutions distributed billions of dollars in Bitcoin at $65,000-$73,000.
I bought it for $67,800. Bought straight from institutions that had accumulated at $28,000. They made 140% profit. I made a loss.

Phase 3: Re-Accumulation (Mid-Late 2024)

What Happened:
Bitcoin crashed 33% to $49,300. Retail panicked and sold. “Halving was a scam!” “Bitcoin is dead!”
Institutions? Buying again.
The Proof:
Whale addresses (wallets holding 1,000+ Bitcoin) increased their holdings significantly from July to October 2024. While retail sold at $50,000-$55,000, institutions accumulated.
I sold at $51,200. Sold straight to institutions preparing for the next leg up. They’ll make 100%+ profit. I locked in a loss.

Phase 4: The Real Rally (Late 2024 – 2025)

What’s Happening Now:
Bitcoin rallied from $49,300 (August) to $103,800 (December 2024). Currently consolidating around $95,000-$100,000 as of December 20, 2024.
Retailers who panic-sold in August are experiencing FOMO again. Some are buying back at higher prices than they sold.
Institutions that accumulated at $50,000-$60,000 are sitting on 60-80% gains, waiting for the euphoria phase in 2025 to distribute again.
The Cycle Repeats.

The Real 2025 Bitcoin Halving Thesis

Okay, so what’s the actual play for 2025? Not the hype. The reality.

Where We Are Now (December 2024)

Bitcoin’s at $95,000-$103,000 range. The post-halving crash already happened (August $49,300 low). We’re in the early stages of the real bull run that historically peaks 12-18 months post-halving.
Timeline Math:
  • Halving: April 20, 2024
  • 12 months later: April 2025
  • 18 months later: October 2025
Historical patterns say Bitcoin peaks somewhere between April and October 2025.

What Could Go Right

Scenario 1: Historical Pattern Holds
If this cycle mimics 2016-2017 or 2020-2021, Bitcoin could hit:
  • Conservative: $120,000-$150,000 (April-June 2025)
  • Moderate: $150,000-$180,000 (July-September 2025)
  • Optimistic: $180,000-$220,000 (October-December 2025)
Scenario 2: Institutional Demand Amplifies Cycle
Bitcoin ETFs brought $20+ billion in new institutional money. If that continues:
  • Bullish case: $200,000-$250,000 (Q3-Q4 2025)

What Could Go Wrong

Scenario 1: Early Peak (February-April 2025)
Sometimes halvings peak earlier than expected. If Bitcoin hits $120,000-$140,000 by March 2025, then crashes, retail who FOMO in at $130,000+ gets wrecked again.
Scenario 2: Macro Breaks the Cycle
Recession, geopolitical crisis, regulatory crackdown—any of these could break the halving pattern. Bitcoin could peak at $110,000, then enter a multi-year bear market.
Scenario 3: The Shakeout Isn’t Over
Maybe Bitcoin needs one more crash to $70,000-$80,000 before the real rally. This would liquidate late buyers at $95,000+ and reset sentiment.

My Personal Stance (Not Financial Advice)

I’m not buying Bitcoin at $95,000-$100,000. I already missed the $50,000- $60,000 accumulation zone by panic-selling.
My Plan:
If Bitcoin drops to $75,000-$80,000, I’ll buy with 20% of my crypto allocation. That’s a 20% dip from current levels—enough shakeout to reset sentiment.
If Bitcoin rallies to $130,000-$140,000, I’m watching for distribution signs (increasing exchange inflows, declining volume on rallies, bearish RSI divergences). That’s likely the top.
If Bitcoin hits $150,000+: I’m not chasing. I missed this cycle. I’ll accumulate during the next bear market at $40,000-$60,000 in 2026-2027.
I’ve learned my lesson. Don’t FOMO into parabolic rallies. Don’t panic sell during crashes. Buy when nobody’s talking about Bitcoin. Sell when your taxi driver gives you crypto tips.

How to Actually Trade the Next Halving (2028)

Since I butchered the 2024 halving, here’s what I’ll do differently in 2028.

Phase 1: Accumulate 12-18 Months BEFORE Halving

The 2028 Halving Timeline:
Expected halving date: March-April 2028
Accumulation Window: October 2026 – March 2027
That’s when Bitcoin will be boring. Down 60-70% from the 2025 peak. Retail will call it dead. Perfect buying opportunity.
My Strategy:
Dollar-cost average $100-$200 per month during that window. Not timing the exact bottom. Just accumulating while nobody cares.

Phase 2: Take Profits BEFORE the Halving

The Mistake I Made:
Bought 3 weeks before halving, expecting immediate gains after. Didn’t realize the rally happens before the halving, not after.
2028 Strategy:
If Bitcoin rallies 100-150% in the 6 months before halving (October 2027 – March 2028), I’m taking 50% profits regardless of FOMO.
The pre-halving rally is a gift. Don’t be greedy.

Phase 3: Expect the Post-Halving Crash

The Mistake I Made:
Panic sold during the inevitable post-halving crash. Didn’t know it was normal.
2028 Strategy:
After halving, if Bitcoin crashes 25-35%, I’m adding to my position, not selling. That’s the accumulation phase before the real bull run.

Phase 4: Sell Into Euphoria (12-18 Months Post-Halving)

The Mistake I Made:
Wasn’t holding Bitcoin anymore by the time euphoria hit in December 2024.
2028 Strategy:
12-18 months after halving (March 2029 – September 2029), when Bitcoin’s making all-time highs and everyone’s talking about $500,000 Bitcoin—that’s when I sell.
Not because I know the exact top. Because that’s when risk is highest, and greed is maximum.

The Psychology Part (Most Important)

None of this works if you can’t control emotions.
Rules I’m Setting for 2028:
  1. No buying during parabolic rallies. If Bitcoin’s up 40%+ in a month, I’m not buying more.
  2. No selling during crashes. If Bitcoin’s down 30%+ from its highs, I’m holding or adding, not panic-selling.
  3. No listening to crypto Twitter during extremes. When everyone’s bullish, be cautious. When everyone’s bearish, be greedy.
  4. Take profits in stages. Not trying to time the exact top. Sell 20% at each target level on the way up.
  5. Keep receipts. Screenshot all the “Bitcoin to $1 million” predictions at the top. Reminds me what peak euphoria looks like.

The Brutal Math of My Mistake

Let me show you the exact financial damage of my panic selling.
What I Actually Did:
  • Bought: $2,400 at $67,800 (March 2024)
  • Sold: $51,200 (August 2024)
  • Received: $1,814
  • Loss: -$586 (plus transaction fees ≈ $30)
  • Total Loss: -$616
What Would’ve Happened If I Held:
  • Original investment: $2,400 at $67,800
  • Bitcoin at $103,800 (December 2024)
  • Portfolio value: $3,670
  • Gain: +$1,270
The Difference:
By panic selling, I’m down $1,270 in gains + $616 in realized losses = $1,886 total opportunity cost.
On a $2,400 investment, that’s a 78.5% mistake.
And Bitcoin hasn’t even peaked yet. If it hits $150,000 in 2025, my panic sell will have cost me $4,450 in total gains.
That’s what weak hands cost. That’s what not understanding halving cycles cost me.

What I’d Tell My March 2024 Self

If I could go back and talk to myself right before buying Bitcoin at $67,800, here’s what I’d say:
“You’re about to buy near the top of the pre-halving rally. Don’t.”
“Wait until June-August 2024 when Bitcoin crashes to $50,000-$55,000. Everyone will call Bitcoin dead. That’s when you buy.”
“The halving doesn’t make you rich immediately. It sets up a cycle. Be patient.”
“When Bitcoin drops 30% after halving and you feel sick, that’s the signal to buy more, not sell.”
“Institutions have been accumulating for a year at $28,000. They’re about to sell to you at $68,000. Don’t be their exit liquidity.”
“And for God’s sake, when crypto Twitter is screaming ‘$100,000 Bitcoin by July!’ and everyone’s euphoric—that’s the top. Sell. Don’t buy.”
But I couldn’t tell myself that. So I learned the expensive way.
You don’t have to.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will Bitcoin definitely go up after the 2024 halving?

Nothing’s definite. Historically, Bitcoin has rallied by 650-9,800% within 12-18 months after each halving. But past performance doesn’t guarantee future results. The 2024-2025 cycle could differ due to institutional involvement, macroeconomic conditions, or regulatory changes. Never invest more than you can afford to lose.

When will Bitcoin hit its next all-time high?

Based on historical halving cycles, Bitcoin typically peaks 12-18 months after each halving. The April 2024 halving suggests a potential peak between April and October 2025. However, Bitcoin already hit new all-time highs in December 2024 at $103,800. This could mean an earlier peak (Q1-Q2 2025) or a multi-peak cycle.

Why did Bitcoin crash after the halving if supply decreased?

Miner capitulation. Halving cuts miner revenue in half while costs stay constant. Inefficient miners are forced to sell their Bitcoin reserves to survive, creating selling pressure for 2-4 months after the halving. This happened in 2012, 2016, 2020, and 2024—every single halving.

Is it too late to buy Bitcoin in December 2024?

Depends on your timeframe. If Bitcoin follows historical patterns and peaks at $150,000-$200,000 in 2025, buying at $95,000-$100,000 could still yield 50-100% gains. But you missed the post-halving accumulation zone ($50,000-$60,000) where risk-reward was best. At current prices, the risk of buying near a local top is higher.

How high can Bitcoin go in 2025?

Conservative estimates: $120,000-$150,000. Moderate: $150,000-$180,000. Optimistic: $180,000-$250,000. These are based on historical halving cycle performance multipliers. However, diminishing returns are likely—each cycle produces lower percentage gains as Bitcoin’s market cap grows. Don’t expect 10,000% gains like 2012-2013.

When’s the next Bitcoin halving after 2024?

The fifth Bitcoin halving is expected around March-April 2028. Block rewards will drop from 3.125 BTC to 1.5625 BTC per block. If historical patterns continue, the best accumulation window would be October 2026 – March 2027 during the post-2025 bear market.

Can I still make money if I missed the $50,000 Bitcoin dip?

Yes, but risk-reward is lower. Buying at $95,000-$100,000 with targets of $150,000-$180,000 offers 50-80% upside. That’s still significant, but you’re also risking buying near a local or cycle top. Dollar-cost averaging over 3-6 months reduces timing risk compared to lump-sum investing at current prices.

What’s the biggest mistake retail traders make during halvings?

Expecting immediate results. Retail buys the pre-halving rally (buying the top), panics during the post-halving crash (selling the bottom), then misses the real bull run 12-18 months later. The cycle punishes impatience and rewards patience. I made this exact mistake and cost myself $1,886 in opportunity cost.

Conclusion: The Lesson That Cost Me $1,886

The 2024 Bitcoin halving taught me what no YouTube video or Twitter thread ever could—market cycles don’t care about hype. They follow patterns driven by supply, demand, and human psychology.
I bought into FOMO at $67,800, thinking I was early. I was late.
I panic-sold at $51,200, thinking Bitcoin was done. It wasn’t.
I missed the $103,800 rally four months later. That mistake cost me $1,886 and counting.
But here’s what I gained: understanding. The next halving in 2028, I won’t buy the pre-halving euphoria. I’ll accumulate during the boring 2026-2027 bear market when nobody’s talking about crypto. I won’t panic sell during the post-halving crash—I’ll buy more. And when euphoria hits in 2029, and everyone’s predicting $500,000 Bitcoin, I’ll sell.
Not because I’ll time it perfectly. Because I finally understand the game.
Bitcoin halvings don’t make retail traders rich in six months. They create a multi-year cycle that rewards patience and punishes FOMO. If you’re reading this in December 2024, thinking about buying Bitcoin at $95,000, understand what phase of the cycle you’re in. We’re likely in the early-to-mid bull market phase, not the beginning.
The best entry was $50,000-$60,000 (August-September 2024). That’s gone. The next best entry might be a potential dip to $75,000-$80,000 if it comes. Or it might be accumulating in the 2026-2027 bear market at $40,000-$60,000.
What I won’t do: FOMO into parabolic rallies. That’s what destroyed me this cycle. Won’t happen again.
For more context on cryptocurrency market cycles and security, see our complete crypto trading guide and crypto security strategies.

⚠️ Financial Disclaimer

Risk Warning: Cryptocurrency trading, including Bitcoin, involves extreme risk of total capital loss. This content serves educational purposes exclusively—not professional investment advice.
Important Notices:
  • I’m not a certified financial advisor or licensed investment professional.
  • My personal trading results (including my $1,886 loss) don’t predict your outcomes.
  • You can lose your entire cryptocurrency investment—it’s volatile and unpredictable.
  • Only invest money you’re completely prepared to lose.
  • Bitcoin can drop 50-80% during bear markets, regardless of halving cycles.
  • Past halving performance doesn’t guarantee future results.
Specific Bitcoin Halving Warnings:
  • Historical patterns can break—2024-2025 cycle may not follow 2012-2020 patterns.
  • Regulatory crackdowns could destroy Bitcoin’s value overnight.
  • Institutional manipulation creates risks that individual traders can’t predict
  • FOMO and panic selling destroy more capital than market movements
  • Buying near all-time highs ($95,000-$103,000 in December 2024) carries significant drawdown risk.
Before Investing:
Conduct extensive research beyond this article. Understand you’re speculating, not investing safely. Bitcoin isn’t a get-rich-quick scheme—it’s a high-risk asset that’s destroyed countless retail traders who expected easy profits.
Consult licensed financial professionals, understand tax implications, and never borrow money to buy Bitcoin. The strategies and timeline predictions shared represent my personal speculation and may be completely wrong.

About the Author

Saad Sultan is an independent cryptocurrency trader based in Hyderabad, Pakistan, with 3+ years of experience in financial markets, including 18+ months of active Bitcoin and cryptocurrency trading.
Background:
  • 3+ years total trading experience (2021-present)
  • 18 months focused on cryptocurrency markets
  • Personally experienced the 2024 Bitcoin halving cycle (with losses)
  • Lost $1,886 in opportunity cost through panic selling at $51,200
  • Self-taught through painful real-money lessons and cycle analysis
  • Not a licensed financial advisor or certified investment professional
Bitcoin Halving Experience:
Saad bought Bitcoin at $67,800 in March 2024 (three weeks before halving), panic-sold at $51,200 in August 2024 during the post-halving crash, and watched Bitcoin rally to $103,800 by December without him. This $1,886 mistake taught him halving cycle patterns the expensive way.
Current Position:
Not holding Bitcoin as of December 2024. Waiting for a potential dip to $75,000-$80,000 or accumulating during the next bear market (2026-2027) at $40,000-$60,000. Focused on learning cycle psychology rather than chasing the current rally.
Philosophy:
Bitcoin halvings create multi-year cycles that reward patience and destroy FOMO. The best entries happen when nobody’s talking about crypto (bear markets), not during euphoric rallies. Retail traders who expect immediate post-halving gains get slaughtered every cycle. Understanding the pattern matters more than timing the exact bottom.
Disclaimer: Saad shares personal cryptocurrency experiences for educational purposes only. He is not a licensed financial professional. All investment decisions should be made after conducting your own research and consulting licensed advisors. His trading mistakes are shared as cautionary tales, not investment recommendations.
📧 Contact: saadsultan537@gmail.com
📍 Location: Hyderabad, Sindh, Pakistan

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Table of Contents

→ Index
Scroll to Top